Skip to main content

Jeremiah's Italian Ice

β˜…4.5(27 reviews)$Ice Cream
πŸ•‘ 20-30 minutesπŸ‘Ά Perfect for all ages, from toddlers to teens. Little ones enjoy the smooth, spoonable texture that's easier to eat than hard ice cream, while older kids love experimenting with wild flavor combinations and the fun, colorful presentation.

About

Jeremiah's Italian Ice is a Casselberry favorite where kids can cool off with creamy Italian ice in a rainbow of flavors, from classic cherry to adventurous options like sour gummy bear. The relaxed outdoor atmosphere means parents don't have to worry about mess, and the affordable prices make it easy to let everyone try multiple flavors or create their own custom Gelati (Italian ice layered with soft ice cream).

Highlights

  • βœ“Over 40 rotating Italian ice flavors from traditional to creative options like Rainbow Ice and Cotton Candy
  • βœ“Gelati combinations that layer Italian ice with soft serve ice cream
  • βœ“Kid-sized portions available that are perfect for little appetites
  • βœ“Fun outdoor atmosphere where spills and sticky hands aren't a concern
  • βœ“Friendly staff who genuinely help kids choose and offer samples

Pro Tips

  1. 1.Ask for sample spoons so kids can try flavors before committing,staff are generous with tastings and it prevents meltdowns over flavor choices
  2. 2.Order the Gelati (Italian ice with soft serve layered in) for a creamier treat that satisfies both ice cream and Italian ice lovers
  3. 3.Visit on Wednesday evenings when they sometimes offer special promotions and new flavor tastings
  4. 4.Bring cash if possible as it speeds up ordering during busy times, though they do accept cards
  5. 5.The outdoor seating area can get hot in summer,plan for a quick treat rather than lingering, or visit after sunset

Best Time to Visit

Weekday evenings around 7-8 PM offer shorter lines and cooler temperatures, perfect for an after-dinner treat. Avoid weekend afternoons when lines can stretch 15-20 minutes during peak summer months.

What to Know

Prices are very budget-friendly at under $10 per family typically. It's an outdoor walk-up window with patio seating, so dress casually and expect to enjoy your treats outside. Parking is convenient in the shopping plaza lot.

Seasonal Notes

Peak season runs spring through early fall when Florida heat makes Italian ice most appealing. They may offer holiday-themed flavors around Halloween and Christmas. Operating hours may vary during winter months, so check ahead during November-February.

Nearby Eats

Since this is a dessert spot, pair it with dinner at nearby Metro Diner (comfort food with great kids menu) or Tijuana Flats (build-your-own tacos that kids enjoy) both within a mile in the same general shopping area.

More Activities Near Casselberry

Park

Twin Rivers Park

β˜…4.8Free

Twin Rivers Park is a hidden gem offering families the perfect blend of active play and peaceful relaxation. The well-maintained playground keeps little ones entertained while open fields provide plenty of space for soccer games, frisbee, or kite flying. Shaded pavilion areas and scenic walking trails make this an ideal spot for family picnics and outdoor quality time.

Activity

Casselberry Art House

β˜…4.8$

Casselberry Art House is a charming lakeside community arts center that brings out the creative spirit in kids of all ages. With hands-on family workshops, age-appropriate art classes, and rotating exhibitions in a historic setting, it's the perfect spot to introduce children to painting, sculpting, and other artistic mediums in a welcoming, non-intimidating environment.

Park

Secret Lake Park

β˜…4.7Free

Secret Lake Park is a hidden gem in Casselberry that offers families a perfect blend of outdoor recreation and natural beauty. With its well-maintained playground, shaded picnic areas, and scenic walking trails along the lakefront, it's an ideal spot for everything from casual afternoon outings to special family picnics with breathtaking sunset views.

Park

Lake Concord Park

β˜…4.7Free

Lake Concord Park is a family favorite in Casselberry that truly has something for everyone. With its well-maintained playground equipment, open sports fields for impromptu games, basketball courts for older kids, and beautiful lake views perfect for feeding ducks or taking a scenic stroll, this park delivers hours of outdoor fun without the crowds of larger theme parks.