Skip to main content

Sylas & Maddy's Homemade Ice Cream

4.7(333 reviews)$$Ice Cream
🕑 30-45 minutes including ordering, eating, and cleanup👶 Perfect for all ages! Toddlers delight in classic flavors and watching the colorful ice cream being scooped, while older kids and teens love sampling adventurous combinations like lavender honey or salted caramel pretzel. Even picky eaters will find something they love from the extensive flavor lineup.

About

Sylas & Maddy's is an Overland Park institution where families gather for seriously delicious homemade ice cream in creative flavors that go way beyond vanilla and chocolate. With generous portions, friendly staff, and a rotating menu of unique flavors, this local favorite has been creating sweet memories for Kansas City families for years.

Highlights

  • Incredible homemade ice cream with 32+ rotating flavors
  • Generous portion sizes that often require sharing
  • Unique seasonal and creative flavors beyond typical ice cream shops
  • Friendly staff who encourage sampling before ordering
  • Local, family-owned business with multiple convenient locations

Pro Tips

  1. 1.Arrive before 7pm on weekends to avoid the after-dinner rush when lines can stretch out the door
  2. 2.Ask for samples before committing,the staff is generous with tastings and it's a fun way for kids to try adventurous flavors
  3. 3.Check their social media for flavor announcements; they rotate seasonal specials and limited-edition creations regularly
  4. 4.Parking can be tight during peak hours, so consider visiting mid-afternoon for easier access
  5. 5.Portions are huge,consider sharing or ordering the smaller size, especially for young kids

Best Time to Visit

Mid-afternoon on weekdays (2-4pm) offers the shortest wait times and easier parking. Summer evenings are busiest but most festive. Winter visits mean no crowds and cozy seasonal flavors like peppermint bark.

What to Know

Expect to spend $5-8 per person for generous scoops. Parking is shared with other businesses in the strip mall. Cash and cards accepted, and there's limited indoor seating, so plan to eat in your car or take it to-go.

Seasonal Notes

Open year-round with seasonal flavor rotations. Summer brings fruit-forward flavors and longest hours. Fall features pumpkin and apple varieties. Winter showcases peppermint and holiday specials. Check hours before visiting as they may vary by season.

More Activities Near Overland Park

Park

Overland Park Arboretum & Botanical Gardens

4.8Free

This sprawling 300-acre natural sanctuary offers families an incredible outdoor escape with well-maintained trails winding through diverse ecosystems, plus a magical butterfly garden that captivates kids of all ages. Best of all, admission is completely free, making it an ideal spot for regular family nature walks without breaking the budget.

Sports

Scheels

4.6Free

Scheels in Overland Park transforms ordinary shopping into an adventure destination that kids actually beg to visit. This massive sporting goods store features a 16-foot saltwater aquarium, indoor Ferris wheel, interactive arcade games, and impressive wildlife displays that keep children entertained while parents shop for quality gear and apparel.

Sports

Scheels Overland Park Soccer Complex

4.6$

Scheels Overland Park Soccer Complex is a premier youth sports destination that goes beyond just soccer games. With multiple well-maintained fields, dedicated playgrounds, and scenic walking paths, it's perfect for families whether you're watching a tournament, practicing skills, or just enjoying outdoor recreation time together.

Park

South Lake Park

4.6Free

South Lake Park is an Overland Park gem that offers something for every family member. With a scenic fishing lake, well-maintained playground, winding walking trails, and plenty of shaded picnic spots, this spacious park is perfect for everything from quick afternoon outings to full-day family adventures. The park's central location and excellent facilities have earned it a stellar 4.6-star rating from over a thousand families.