Skip to main content

Andy's Frozen Custard

β˜…4.3(8 reviews)$Ice Cream
πŸ•‘ 20-30 minutes including ordering and enjoying treatsπŸ‘Ά Perfect for all ages! Toddlers and preschoolers love watching the custard being mixed and choosing their mix-ins, while older kids and teens enjoy the wide variety of flavor combinations. Even picky eaters can find something they'll love with the simple vanilla or chocolate options.

About

Andy's Frozen Custard is a beloved local treat destination where families can indulge in creamy, freshly-made frozen custard served in generous portions. Kids will be delighted by the colorful concrete mixers,thick custard blended with candy, cookies, or fruit,while parents appreciate the quality ingredients and friendly service that make this a go-to spot for celebrating everything from good report cards to Little League victories.

Highlights

  • βœ“Fresh frozen custard made throughout the day with real ingredients
  • βœ“Concrete mixers blended with endless candy, cookie, and fruit combinations
  • βœ“Seasonal flavors and special creations that rotate regularly
  • βœ“Friendly staff who are patient with kids deciding on flavors
  • βœ“Jackets (custard and toppings layered in a cup) for those who want variety without blending

Pro Tips

  1. 1.Visit during off-peak hours (mid-afternoon on weekdays) to avoid long lines, especially during summer months when waits can stretch 15-20 minutes
  2. 2.Order a small first,Andy's portions are extremely generous and even kids' sizes are substantial enough to share with younger toddlers
  3. 3.Bring cash for tipping the enthusiastic staff, though they accept cards for payment
  4. 4.Park toward the back of the lot during busy times as the front spaces fill quickly, and families with strollers will appreciate the extra room
  5. 5.Ask for a sample before committing to a flavor if your child is indecisive,the staff is happy to help

Best Time to Visit

Weekday afternoons (2-4pm) offer the shortest waits and a relaxed atmosphere. Summer evenings after 7pm get very crowded with families, so plan accordingly. Winter visits are surprisingly pleasant as the shop is open year-round and lines are much shorter.

What to Know

Expect to spend $5-8 per person for a generous serving. Parking is plentiful in the shared strip mall lot. Outdoor seating is available, but limited indoor seating means you may enjoy your custard in the car or at nearby park benches.

Seasonal Notes

Open year-round, making it a reliable treat destination even in winter. Summer brings special seasonal flavors and longer hours. Check their social media for limited-time flavor announcements and holiday specials around major celebrations.

More Activities Near O'Fallon

Ice Cream

Main Street Creamery

β˜…4.0$

Main Street Creamery is a delightful throwback ice cream parlor that captures the charm of old-fashioned soda fountains while serving generous portions of hand-dipped ice cream. The nostalgic atmosphere, complete with classic dΓ©cor, makes this a sweet destination where kids can enjoy delicious frozen treats while parents appreciate the cozy, family-friendly vibe that encourages you to slow down and savor the moment.

Activity

Renaud Spirit Center

$

Renaud Spirit Center is O'Fallon's hub for family fitness and fun, offering multiple indoor swimming pools, a well-equipped fitness center, and a rotating calendar of classes designed for all ages. Parents love that they can exercise while kids splash in the pool or participate in youth programs, making it a one-stop destination for active families year-round.

Park

Westhoff Park Connector Trail

Free

Westhoff Park Connector Trail offers families a perfect blend of active recreation and outdoor relaxation in O'Fallon. This well-maintained trail connects to a popular community park with multiple playgrounds, making it ideal for combining a nature walk with playground time. The paved paths are stroller-friendly and great for young cyclists learning to ride.

Adventure

Katy Trail

Free

The Katy Trail in O'Fallon offers families a perfect escape into nature with flat, well-maintained paths ideal for young cyclists and stroller-pushing parents. This scenic section of Missouri's longest rail-trail provides a safe, car-free environment where kids can practice biking skills while spotting wildlife and enjoying the peaceful Missouri River valley landscape. Whether you're introducing toddlers to nature walks or letting older kids build endurance on longer rides, this trail accommodates all family adventure levels.