Photo: Google
Photo: Google
Photo: Google
Milky Way
★3.8(43 reviews)$Ice Cream
🕑 30-45 minutes👶 Great for all ages! Toddlers love the sweet treats and relaxed vibe, while older kids and teens appreciate the variety of flavors and sundae options. The casual setting means even fussy eaters can find something they'll enjoy.
About
A beloved neighborhood ice cream shop in Squirrel Hill that's been delighting Pittsburgh families with homemade ice cream and classic treats. The cozy, old-fashioned atmosphere and generous portions make Milky Way a perfect stop after school activities, weekend outings, or as a special dessert destination that won't break the bank.
Highlights
- ✓Homemade ice cream with rotating flavors
- ✓Classic sundaes and ice cream treats
- ✓Unexpected savory options like pizza and pretzels
- ✓Authentic neighborhood ice cream parlor atmosphere
- ✓Budget-friendly prices perfect for frequent family treats
Pro Tips
- 1.Street parking on Murray Avenue can be tight during peak hours, so try the side streets or consider walking if you're already in Squirrel Hill
- 2.Lines can get long on warm weekend evenings,visit mid-afternoon on weekdays for a quieter experience
- 3.Don't let the 'ice cream' name fool you,they also serve pizza and pretzels, making it a surprisingly flexible option for picky eaters or if you need a quick bite
- 4.Bring cash if possible as some small ice cream shops have minimum card purchases
- 5.Ask about their homemade flavors,the staff is friendly and often has daily specials not listed on the main menu
Best Time to Visit
Weekday afternoons (2-5 PM) offer shorter lines and a relaxed atmosphere. Summer evenings are busiest but have the most festive neighborhood vibe. Winter visits are quieter if your kids love ice cream year-round.
What to Know
Very budget-friendly with most items under $10. Limited seating inside, so be prepared to enjoy treats on-the-go or outside during busy times. Located on busy Murray Avenue with street parking available.
Seasonal Notes
Peak season is summer when families flock for after-dinner ice cream. Hours may be reduced in winter months, so call ahead during colder seasons. A perfect stop after trick-or-treating in fall or to celebrate end of school year.
Follow Milky Way
More Activities Near Squirrel Hill
Park
Frick Park
★4.8Free❤️337
Frick Park is Pittsburgh's largest regional park, spanning over 600 acres of natural beauty in Squirrel Hill. With miles of family-friendly hiking trails, multiple playgrounds, wide open fields for running and playing, and peaceful nature areas, it's a go-to destination for families seeking outdoor adventure without leaving the city.
Playground
Blue Slide Playground
★4.8Free❤️161
Blue Slide Playground is a legendary Pittsburgh destination where generations of families have created memories on its iconic towering blue concrete slide. Located in beautiful Frick Park, this beloved playground combines nostalgic charm with classic play equipment including swings, climbing structures, and plenty of open space for running around.
Playground
Wightman Playground at Wightman Park
★4.8Free❤️70
Wightman Playground is a beloved Squirrel Hill neighborhood gem that consistently earns rave reviews from local families. This well-maintained playground features modern climbing structures and equipment that engage kids of various ages, plus plenty of open grassy space perfect for running, picnicking, or flying kites in a safe residential setting.
Library
Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh - Squirrel Hill
★4.6Free❤️22
The Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh - Squirrel Hill branch is a family favorite, offering much more than books. With engaging storytimes, hands-on activities, and a fantastic children's section, it's the perfect spot for nurturing young readers while keeping little ones entertained. The welcoming atmosphere and excellent programming make it a go-to destination for Pittsburgh families seeking indoor educational fun.