Photo: Google
Photo: Google
Photo: Google
Jeremiah's Italian Ice
★4.4(92 reviews)$Ice Cream
🕑 30-45 minutes👶 Perfect for all ages from toddlers to teens. Little ones love the vibrant colors and smooth texture that's easy to eat, while older kids enjoy customizing their own flavor combinations and trying the rotating seasonal offerings.🧡 Saved by 100+ families
About
Jeremiah's Italian Ice is a beloved family destination in Lake Mary where kids can enjoy refreshing Italian ice in creative flavors, layered with creamy soft serve for the signature "Gelati" combination. The casual outdoor seating, generous portions, and wallet-friendly prices make it the perfect reward after sports practice, school achievements, or just a hot Florida afternoon that calls for a sweet cool-down.
Highlights
- ✓Over 40 rotating Italian ice flavors including kid favorites like Rainbow, Cotton Candy, and Sour Patch Kids
- ✓The signature "Gelati" layering Italian ice with soft serve ice cream in the middle
- ✓Generous portion sizes even the small is substantial for younger children
- ✓Outdoor seating with a festive, colorful atmosphere that feels like a mini celebration
- ✓Dairy-free Italian ice options perfect for kids with allergies or lactose intolerance
Pro Tips
- 1.Go on Wednesday nights for 'Customer Appreciation Night' when small sizes are offered at a discount,great for trying new flavors without breaking the bank
- 2.Ask for a sample spoon before ordering; kids can try multiple flavors to find their favorite since the selection rotates regularly
- 3.Park toward the side of the shopping center for easier access, as the front spots fill up quickly on warm evenings
- 4.Bring wet wipes or napkins,Italian ice can get messy with enthusiastic little eaters, and sticky hands are guaranteed
- 5.Check their social media before visiting to see which limited-time flavors are available that day
Best Time to Visit
Early evening around 6-7 PM on weekdays offers the best experience with shorter lines and pleasant weather. Avoid weekend afternoons when lines can stretch 20+ minutes, especially during summer months and after local youth sports games let out.
What to Know
Most treats cost between $4-7, and it's cash or card friendly. Seating is primarily outdoors under covered areas, so plan accordingly during rainy weather or peak summer heat.
Seasonal Notes
Open year-round, but this is an especially popular spot during Florida's hot summer months (May-September). They often feature special holiday flavors around major celebrations like Halloween and Christmas. Outdoor seating can be less comfortable during July and August peak heat.
Follow Jeremiah's Italian Ice
Nearby Eats
The venue is located in a shopping plaza near Tijuana Flats (casual Tex-Mex with a good kids menu) and Panera Bread, making it easy to grab dinner first and walk over for dessert.
More Activities Near Sanford
Adventure
Seminole Wekiva Trail
Free
The Seminole Wekiva Trail offers families a beautifully paved, flat pathway stretching through Sanford's natural landscapes, making it ideal for introducing kids to outdoor adventures without the challenge of difficult terrain. This multi-use trail winds through shaded forests and scenic areas where families can bike, walk, scooter, or jog together while spotting local wildlife and enjoying Florida's natural beauty in a safe, car-free environment.
Theater
The Ritz Theater/Wayne Densch Performing Arts Center
★4.8$❤️210
Step back in time at this beautifully restored 1923 theater in the heart of downtown Sanford, where families can enjoy Broadway-style productions, children's shows, concerts, and special performances in an intimate, historic setting. With its stunning architecture and excellent acoustics, The Ritz Theater offers kids a magical introduction to live performing arts in a venue that's been entertaining Central Florida families for generations.
Park
Fort Mellon Park
★4.6Free❤️247
Fort Mellon Park is a lakefront gem on Lake Monroe that offers the perfect combination of water play, playground fun, and scenic beauty. With its popular splash pad for cooling off, well-maintained playground equipment, and peaceful riverwalk with stunning water views, this park provides hours of entertainment for families while parents can relax and enjoy the picturesque setting.
Restaurant
Hollerbach's German Restaurant
★4.4$$❤️210
Hollerbach's brings a taste of Bavaria to downtown Sanford with hearty German fare that kids and parents will love. The lively beer garden atmosphere features live oompah music and dancing, creating an entertaining dining experience where children can enjoy schnitzel, bratwurst, and familiar favorites from the kids menu while parents savor authentic German cuisine and craft beers.